Welcome to the pizza paradise of New York City, where 2025 brings a fresh batch of doughy delights! Whether you’re a local pizza pro or a tourist ready to fold your first slice, NYC’s pizzerias are serving up some of the best pies on the planet. We’ve scoured the five boroughs to bring you the top 3 best pizzerias in NYC, packed with flavor, flair, and fun. Get ready to stretch your taste buds and dive into this ultimate NYC pizza guide!
1. Una Pizza Napoletana: The Neapolitan Royalty
Where the Magic Happens
Lower East Side, 175 Orchard St, New York, NY
Why It’s a Winner
Una Pizza Napoletana isn’t just a pizzeria—it’s a pizza pilgrimage! Owned by the legendary Anthony Mangieri, this spot snagged the title of the best pizzeria in the USA for 2025, and it’s easy to see why. Picture this: a wood-fired oven pumping out Neapolitan pies with a puffy, charred crust that’s softer than a cloud. The Margherita pie, with its San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil, is like a love letter to Italy—delivered straight to your plate!
Fun Fact
Mangieri makes every dough by hand each morning, and once it’s gone, it’s gone! So, channel your inner ninja and get there early, or you might miss out on this doughy dream.
Pro Tip
Pair your slice with a glass of natural wine and savor the slow-cooked perfection. It’s worth the wait (and the hype)!
2. L’Industrie Pizzeria: The Slice Sensation
Where the Magic Happens
254 South 2nd Street Brooklyn, NY 11211
Why It’s a Winner
L’Industrie Pizzeria is the slice shop that stole our hearts—and stomachs! Since 2015, Massimo Laveglia has been crafting thin, crispy crusts that are practically begging to be folded. The burrata slice is a game-changer: a classic Margherita topped with creamy burrata that oozes with every bite. It’s been crowned the best pizza slice in the USA for 2025, and locals swear it’s worth the commute (or the line!).
Fun Fact
This place imports fresh ingredients straight from Italy, so every bite feels like a transatlantic trip. Plus, the West Village spot means Manhattanites can join the party too!
Pro Tip
Go for the spicy salami slice if you like a kick, and don’t skip the olive oil soft serve for a quirky dessert twist. Yes, you read that right—pizza and ice cream, baby!
3. Lucia Pizza: The Old-School Cool
Where the Magic Happens
2201 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY 11235
Why It’s a Winner
Lucia Pizza is where old-school meets new-school with a side of swagger! Chef Salvatore Carlino, from a legendary pizza-making family, whips up airy crusts that hold a sweet tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella like champs. The Friday clam pie, with its lemony zing, is a coastal vibe that’ll make you forget you’re in Brooklyn. It’s a 2025 standout that blends tradition with a modern twist—perfect for pizza purists and adventurers alike.
Fun Fact
This spot’s roots trace back to the now-closed Papa Leone Pizzeria, so you’re biting into decades of doughy heritage with every slice!
Pro Tip
Swing by on a Friday for that clam pie magic, and bring friends to share—the portions are generous enough to fuel a pizza party!
Why These Pizzerias Rock NYC in 2025
New York City’s pizza scene is a wild ride, with styles ranging from Neapolitan to New York classics. Una Pizza Napoletana brings the authentic Italian flair, L’Industrie Pizzeria redefines the slice game, and Lucia Pizza keeps the family tradition alive with a fresh spin. These top pizzerias in NYC are buzzing with 2025 energy, drawing crowds from all boroughs and beyond. Whether you’re chasing the best pizza NYC has to offer or just craving a cheesy escape, these spots deliver!
How to Pick Your Pizza Adventure
- For the Purist: Una Pizza Napoletana’s Neapolitan perfection is your go-to.
- For the Slice Lover: L’Industrie Pizzeria’s burrata magic can’t be beat.
- For the Nostalgia Trip: Lucia Pizza’s clam pie will transport you to pizza heaven.
Check their hours, bring cash (some spots are cash-only!), and brace for lines—great pizza is worth the hype. Bonus points if you snap a pic of your pie for the ‘gram!
Final Slice of Fun
There you have it—the top 3 best pizzerias in New York City for 2025! From the Lower East Side to Brooklyn, these spots are serving up slices that’ll make you say, “New York, you’ve done it again!” Grab a friend, pick your favorite, and let the pizza party begin. Got a favorite pie? Drop it in the comments and let’s keep the cheesy debate rolling!
