Frozen pizza has come a long way from cardboard crusts and rubbery cheese. With new innovations in crusts, sauces, and ingredients, today’s frozen pizzas can rival your local pizzeria—at a fraction of the cost. But with so many options in the freezer aisle, which ones are truly worth your money?
We did the taste testing, read the reviews, and analyzed ingredients to bring you the Top 3 Best Frozen Pizzas for quality, flavor, and value.
1. DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Why It’s a Top Pick:
When you think frozen pizza, you think DiGiorno. Known for its signature rising crust, DiGiorno delivers a classic pizza shop experience right from your oven.
Taste Test Results:
- Fluffy, bready crust with a crisp edge
- Generous pepperoni coverage with a bold, slightly spicy flavor
- Tangy tomato sauce with just the right amount of sweetness
- Real mozzarella cheese that browns beautifully when baked
Nutrition & Details:
- 350 calories per serving (1/6 pizza)
- Available nationwide
- Bakes in ~22 minutes at 400°F
Best For: Fans of thick, doughy crust and traditional pepperoni lovers
2. California Pizza Kitchen White Pizza
Why It’s a Top Pick:
Looking for something a little more gourmet? California Pizza Kitchen’s White Pizza offers a premium frozen experience with unique toppings and a thinner, artisan-style crust.
Taste Test Results:
- Crispy, fire-baked crust with a chewy center
- Rich, creamy garlic sauce base (no red sauce)
- Real spinach, ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese
- Balanced, indulgent flavor without being too heavy
Nutrition & Details:
- 320 calories per serving (1/3 pizza)
- Vegetarian-friendly
- Bakes in ~14 minutes at 425°F
Best For: Foodies, vegetarians, and fans of white sauce pizzas
3. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge Cheese
Why It’s a Top Pick:
Cheese lovers, rejoice. Screamin’ Sicilian packs this pizza with heaps of mozzarella, white cheddar, provolone, and parmesan—plus a bold sauce and thick, buttery crust.
Taste Test Results:
- Flavor-packed crust that stays crispy outside and soft inside
- High-quality, gooey cheese blend that melts evenly
- Robust red sauce with garlic, oregano, and a slight kick
- Comes in a quirky box with a “cheese face” cutout for fun
Nutrition & Details:
- 370 calories per serving (1/4 pizza)
- Made with whole milk mozzarella
- Bakes in ~17 minutes at 425°F
Best For: Cheese enthusiasts and those who like bold flavors and hearty crusts
Frozen Pizza Buying Tips
Before tossing a box in your cart, consider these tips for choosing the best frozen pizza:
- Crust type – Do you prefer thin, rising, or deep-dish?
- Ingredient quality – Look for real cheese and minimal preservatives
- Cooking time – Some options bake faster, others need 20+ minutes
- Special diets – Gluten-free, vegetarian, and low-carb options are now widely available
Final Slice
Frozen pizzas have evolved into a reliable, affordable, and sometimes even gourmet meal. Whether you’re after classic pepperoni, a refined white pizza, or a cheesy indulgence, the picks above are your best bet in 2025.
By the way, cooking these frozen pizzas in/on a pizza oven makes all the difference in the world! Check out our list of the Top 3 Pizza Ovens and Top 3 Budget Pizza Cookers.
🛒 Bonus: Want to stock your freezer smartly?
Stay tuned for our next list: Top 3 Gluten-Free Frozen Pizzas Worth Trying.
